Today in Bad Charts

Today in bad charts, I offer you this sample from a new paper on clustering in IPO underwriting commissions. Notice where the black “line” is? The line of data obscures the data.

[Update] As someone suggests in a comment to this post, a histogram would be better.

Related posts:

  1. Me Media: CNBC Power Lunch Today
  2. Today in Nile Floods, Shar’ia and Economic Instability
  3. First Flickr Virus?
  4. Media Investing in Web 2.0, Plus Six Apart’s Financing
  5. Be It Resolved: Online Ad Clutter is Killing Ads


  1. Ben says:

    Paul, the "black line" is the data!

    I'm sure Tufte would say to present this is as a histogram.


  2. @cabezud says:

    I have to agree. The black line is data.

  3. Jack Griffin says:

    Originally saw this on Felix Salmon's blog ( and thought the same thing until I read the comments there. Crazy how the 7% line is so tightly packed to make it seem like the trend line. No big deal, otherwise keep up the great work!

  4. pwclarky says:

    This work seems to update a classic paper by Jay Ritter – "The Seven Percent Solution" :… … similar charts there.